Spatial Questions by Shields Rob

Spatial Questions by Shields Rob

Author:Shields, Rob
Language: eng
Format: epub
ISBN: 9781446286739
Publisher: Sage Publications, Ltd.
Published: 2013-08-14T16:00:00+00:00


Our conceptions are premised on the drawing of bright lines, marking off one individual interest or estate from another. At work here is a particularly sharp logic of Euclidean spatialisation, in which categories are detached, bounded and contained, and imagined as individuated spaces. The production of property thus requires categorical cuts, in which “belonging is … given a boundary.” (Strathern, 1996: 525 cited in Blomley, 2010: 205)

Property requires that subject and object are separated and individuated by physical and symbolic divisions in an ‘ethic of inter-subjective separability’ (Blomley, 2010: 216); that territories are divided rather than being understood as connected, despite the constant boundary-crossing that everyday life entails. Legal discourses of property rights are part and parcel of a specific form of Abstract Space, a spatialisation that parses space into territorial units thereby regulating social relations and promoting the autonomy of the individual.

3. Territoriality originates in psychological studies: a culturally-modified sense of spatiality and territory is accounted for by biological impulses. A territorial principle may be extended from the level of the individual outward from the body through a zone of personal space and further to inter-personal interaction at specific distances (‘proxemics’) to provide an argument for the biological necessity of ‘social territory’. However, the correspondences between social groups and distinct spatial domains become more and more vague the higher one goes in this progression of scale. However, as Simmel demonstrates, there is a variety of cases: the supposed law of spatial integration of groups with a specific territory is not univocal; the social identity of migrants, diasporic communities or nomads may not be directly linked to a territory. Finally, territoriality also obscures the reproduction and change of specific spatial behaviours and of the production of social communities with specific spatial forms (i.e. urban morphology, function) behind a mask of functional necessity.

Social Space has been only implicit in most social science research. Sociologists influenced by Anthony Giddens’ work developed Marx’s notion of the annihilation of space by time as the ‘space-time structuration’ of society, which was similar to but without the benefit of Simmel’s earlier sociology of space or Lefebvre’s critical approach to social spatialisation. The projects of Lefebvre and Giddens differ significantly, despite the many parallels, especially at the superficial level of issuing the rallying cry of ‘Space!’ in the social sciences. Giddens concentrates on the spatial variables of distance and division of territory into symbolically coded regions or places. Both of these variables are subsumed under ‘space’. This is reminiscent of the positivist model-building projects of territoriality and even space syntax.

Giddens comments that the development of an increasing reliance on non-‘face-to-face’ interactions poses problems for social integration. But such observations are of only superficial use; Simmel in 1903 notes that social integration can be accomplished technically using media that have the effect of negating distance, separation, and the isolation of individuals. The community festivals pictured in Breugel’s seventeenth-century artworks are simply not the norm, nor could they be, given the predominantly non-contiguous communities (characterised by temporal and spatial



Download



Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.